live-updates:-netanyahu-offers-full-throated-defense-of-gaza-war

Live Updates: Netanyahu Offers Full-Throated Defense of Gaza War

Annie KarniErica L. Green

Here’s the latest.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu forcefully defended Israel’s military campaign in Gaza during an address on Wednesday to a joint meeting of Congress, in which he praised the Israeli-American alliance and sought to portray the war as a battle between good and evil, civilization and barbarism.

Mr. Netanyahu said the war against Hamas was part of a larger conflict between Iran and the United States, and he said America must stand with Israel to defend their common values.

“My friends, if you remember one thing, one thing from this speech, remember this,” Mr. Netanyahu said. “Our enemies are your enemies. Our fight is your fight. And our victory will be your victory.”

He also lavished praise on both President Biden and former President Donald J. Trump. He largely avoided talking about differences of opinion between himself and President Biden and instead directed anger at antiwar protesters, whom he accused of sympathizing with terrorists and acting as “Iran’s useful idiots.”

He did not mention a cease-fire by name, or discuss the status of the deal that Israel and Hamas have been negotiating for weeks and that the Biden administration desperately wants to get done. He did say that the war could end if Hamas surrendered, disarmed and returned hostages.

Mr. Netanyahu received repeated applause from Republican senators and representatives seated in the House chamber for the joint meeting, which dozens of Democratic lawmakers declined to attend, including two top senators and Representative Nancy Pelosi, the former House speaker.

Vice President Kamala Harris declined to preside over the session, as is traditional for the vice president, citing a scheduling conflict. Nearly 100 House and Senate interns called in sick to protest the speech.

Mr. Netanyahu laid out a vision for the day after the war ends, saying that after Israel defeats Hamas “a new Gaza could emerge,” and that Israel had no plans to “resettle” Gaza. That is an issue that Ms. Harris — now the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee — has been pressing since the war began.

Outside the Capitol, more than 5,000 pro-Palestinian demonstrators gathered to protest the speech, some wearing Palestinian scarves, chanting for the United States to stop arming Israel. Some carried signs calling Mr. Netanyahu a “war criminal” and the “prime minister of genocide.”

Here’s what to know:

  • In Gaza: The death toll since the war began more than nine months ago has surpassed 39,000, according to the health authorities in the enclave, whose numbers do not distinguish between civilians and combatants. Israel has been attacking areas of eastern Khan Younis, a city in southern Gaza, that it had previously designated as a humanitarian zone, saying that militants were firing rockets and Hamas was attempting to regroup there. More than 270 aid workers have been killed during the war, according to the United Nations.

  • Cease-fire talks: While both sides have agreed to the broad outlines of a three-phase cease-fire deal, negotiations to end the war in Gaza and free the hostages appear to have reached a standstill. On Thursday, a delegation of Israeli negotiators is expected to meet with mediators abroad, according to Mr. Netanyahu’s office, but it is not clear where the meetings will be held or how high-level they will be. Israel says it will only agree to a permanent cease-fire after Hamas’s elimination and the return of the 120 living and dead hostages in Gaza. Hamas has said it will not return any of the hostages unless Israel provides a path to a permanent cease-fire. At the same time, Hamas has resisted calls to abandon its control of the Gaza Strip, which it has ruled since 2007.

  • Meeting candidates: Mr. Netanyahu will meet with Ms. Harris in Washington on Thursday, after a separate meeting with President Biden. The two men will also meet with family members of Americans held hostage by Hamas, the White House said. The Israeli leader will then travel to Florida to meet with former President Donald J. Trump at his private club, Mar-a-Lago, on Friday. The Israeli leader was invited to Washington weeks ago, before Mr. Biden’s decision not to seek re-election. The relationship between Mr. Biden and Mr. Netanyahu has grown testier in recent months as the war has dragged on.

Anjana Sankar

Hostage families, both in Israel and the U.S., have criticized Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s speech to Congress for not addressing the plight of hostages held in Gaza or hastening steps to secure a cease-fire deal that would allow their release. Hundreds of families who had gathered in Tel Aviv to watch the speech were disappointed that he did not announce a deal, but instead defended the war in Gaza.

“The words ‘Deal Now!’ were absent from the Prime Minister’s address,” the Hostages and Missing Families Forum, an advocacy group, said in a statement. “There was also no mention of the 120 hostages who, once again tonight, will not return home.” The Israeli military has so far confirmed the death of 44 hostages.

Anushka Patil

At least two family members of Israeli hostages were arrested by Capitol Police during Netanyahu’s speech to Congress, according to groups representing the families. One, Carmit Katzir, was removed from the gallery while wearing a yellow T-shirt that called for Netanyahu to immediately “seal the deal” for the hostages’ release, the Hostages and Missing Families Forum confirmed.

Anushka Patil

Katzir’s father was killed during the Oct. 7 attacks and her mother and brother were taken hostage, according to the Israeli military. While her mother was released as part of a brief cease-fire deal in November, the Israeli military said her brother was killed in captivity in January. “He could have been saved if there had been a deal in time,” Katzir said when his body was later recovered. “But our leadership are cowards.”


Protests outside the Capitol

  1. Pro-Palestinian demonstrators outside the Capitol on Wednesday.

    Jason Andrew for The New York Times

  2. Eric Lee/The New York Times

  3. Brent McDonald/The New York Times

  4. Officers in riot gear using pepper spray.

    Eric Lee/The New York Times

  5. Protestors hit with pepper spray receiving assistance.

    Jason Andrew for The New York Times

  6. By Reuters

  7. Eric Lee/The New York Times

  8. Kenny Holston/The New York Times

  9. Jason Andrew for The New York Times

  10. Brent McDonald/The New York Times

  11. Jason Andrew for The New York Times

Minho Kim

Hundreds of protesters are still chanting “free free Palestine” and banging drums in front of the U.S. District Court, across Pennsylvania Avenue from the east wing of the National Gallery of Arts. Pennsylvania Avenue remains closed to vehicular traffic.

Laurence Tan

As Israeli continued its strikes on parts of Khan Younis, in southern Gaza, Palestinians carried bodies to the city’s Nasser Hospital, and injured Palestinians received treatment, sometimes outside. An Israeli bombardment of the area on Monday killed 73 people, the Gazan health ministry said on Tuesday.

Image

Credit…Bashar Taleb/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Image

Credit…Bashar Taleb/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Cassandra Vinograd

Netanyahu portrayed Iran as the main threat to Israel. Here is some context.

Image

A billboard depicting missiles in Tehran, after the Iranian strike on Israel in April.Credit…Arash Khamooshi for The New York Times

In his speech to Congress on Wednesday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel addressed the threat to his country posed by Iran, which has clashed with Israel for decades.

He also portrayed Iran as a dangerous enemy of the United States and emphasized the role Israel has played as America’s strongest ally in the Middle East.

“When we fight Iran, we are fighting the most radical and dangerous” opponent of America, Mr. Netanyahu said, adding, “We are not only protecting ourselves, we are protecting you.”

Ever since the 1979 revolution that made Iran a Shiite Muslim theocracy, the country has been isolated and has seen itself as besieged. Iran considers the United States and Israel its biggest enemies, and its leaders have long vowed to destroy Israel. It also wants to establish itself as the most powerful nation in the Persian Gulf region, where its chief rival is Saudi Arabia, an American ally.

For the United States and its allies, concerns about Iran are often focused on the risk that it could develop a nuclear weapon. But for Israel, the threat is much more immediate, with Iran using proxies in other countries to strike Israeli interests.

Here are some ways that Iran has clashed with Israel.

Through Hamas: This Palestinian group has received weapons and training from Iran and has fought repeated wars with Israel. Iranian officials have publicly denied being involved in or ordering Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack on Israel that killed about 1,200 people. But they also praised the assault as a momentous achievement and warned that their regional network would open multiple fronts against Israel if the country kept up its retaliatory war against Hamas in Gaza.

Through Hezbollah: A Lebanon-based militia that is widely considered to be the most powerful and sophisticated of the Iran-allied forces, Hezbollah was founded in the 1980s with Iranian assistance, specifically to fight the Israeli occupation of southern Lebanon. The group, which is also a political party in Lebanon, has fought multiple wars and border skirmishes with Israel.

Hezbollah has been trading fire across the border with Israel’s military almost daily since the Oct. 7 attack, and the risk of all-out war is higher than ever. A cease-fire in Gaza could reduce that threat.

Through the Houthis: The Houthi movement in Yemen launched an insurgency against the government two decades ago. What was once a ragtag rebel force gained power thanks at least in part to covert military aid from Iran, according to American and Middle Eastern officials and analysts.

Since the war in Gaza began, the Houthis have waged what they call a campaign in solidarity with Palestinians. They have disrupted a significant part of the world’s shipping by attacking vessels heading to or from the Suez Canal and have launched missiles and drones at Israel, including a drone that hit an apartment building in Tel Aviv last week, killing one person. Israel hit a Yemeni port in retaliation.

Direct attacks: Israel has long carried out targeted assassinations of Iranian military leaders and nuclear scientists, but in April it took the bold step of killing several high-ranking Iranian officials in a strike on an Iranian government building in Syria.

Senior Israeli officials believed that such a brazen assault would act as a deterrent against Iran. Instead, the attack achieved the opposite, prompting Iran to target Israel with one of the largest barrages of ballistic missiles and drones in military history and turning what had been a shadow war into a more open conflict. Israel responded with a more limited strike.

Minho Kim

The Metropolitan police are now taking down the Palestinian flags that protesters raised on three flagpoles in front of Union Station after removing three U.S. flags. Earlier in the day, some protesters tried to burn the American flags, along with an effigy of Benjamin Netanyahu.

Robert Jimison

Representative Nancy Pelosi, the former House speaker, did not attend Benjamin Netanyahu’s address to Congress on Wednesday, but she apparently listened. Writing on social media, she said that his speech was “by far the worst presentation of any foreign dignitary invited and honored with the privilege of addressing the Congress of the United States.”

Noting that she had spent her time today meeting with Israeli citizens whose families were killed or taken hostage by Hamas on Oct. 7, she wrote, “These families are asking for a ceasefire deal that will bring the hostages home – and we hope the Prime Minister would spend his time achieving that goal.”

Aaron Boxerman

Netanyahu has recently signaled hope on cease-fire talks, but there are major stumbling blocks.

Image

Families of people being held hostage in Gaza rallied in Tel Aviv on Tuesday.Credit…Abir Sultan/EPA, via Shutterstock

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel spoke to Congress on Wednesday after weeks in which negotiations to end the war in Gaza and free the hostages appeared to reach a standstill.

Mr. Netanyahu signaled cautious optimism on Monday during a meeting with the families of Israeli hostages held in Gaza. “The conditions are continuing to ripen,” he said, according to his office. But nine months into Israel’s campaign against Hamas in Gaza, the two sides remain fundamentally divided over when and how the war should end.

Israel says it will only agree to a permanent cease-fire after Hamas’s elimination and the return of the 120 living and dead hostages in Gaza. Hamas has said it will not return any of the hostages unless Israel provides a path to a permanent cease-fire. At the same time, Hamas has resisted calls to abandon its control of the Gaza Strip, which it has ruled since 2007.

On Thursday, a delegation of Israeli negotiators is expected to meet with mediators abroad, according to the prime minister’s office. It was not clear where the meetings would be held or how high-level they would be.

Both sides have agreed to the broad outlines of a three-phase cease-fire deal. It would begin with a six-week truce, during which some hostages would be released in exchange for Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli jails. Israel and Hamas would then negotiate over terms for a permanent cease-fire and the withdrawal of Israeli forces in the second and third stages.

That framework has been backed by President Biden and broadly endorsed by the United Nations. Israel’s government also privately greenlit the proposal, although Mr. Netanyahu took weeks to publicly and unequivocally endorse it.

Analysts say that Mr. Netanyahu has sought to buy time, balancing competing demands at home and abroad while avoiding tough decisions that would jeopardize his political standing.

The end of the war would most likely revive a national reckoning over Mr. Netanyahu’s failure to prevent the Hamas-led surprise attack on Oct. 7 that set off the war. And it could topple his government: His hard-right coalition partners have vowed to oppose any deal that would effectively leave Hamas in power in Gaza.

Earlier this month, Hamas submitted its latest counteroffer on the deal framework. U.S. and Israeli officials said Hamas had made some concessions, allowing the talks to move forward. But despite meetings involving Israel, the United States and the regional mediators Egypt and Qatar, there has been little reported progress.

At the same time, Mr. Netanyahu has publicized a new list of conditions for a deal. Israel must be allowed to continue fighting against Hamas should it choose to do so, he said, and it will not allow “thousands of armed terrorists” to return to northern Gaza.

Israeli officials have also demanded guarantees to ensure that Hamas cannot rearm itself by smuggling weapons into Gaza from Egypt. Israel and Egypt have discussed proposals including installing electronic sensors that could detect efforts to dig tunnels under the border, as well as constructing underground barriers to block tunnel construction.

Minho Kim

The Metropolitan Police, members of the New York Police Department and armed members of the U.S. Park police have blocked an intersection near Union Station, and are apparently poised to push out the remaining protesters at Columbus Circle.

Aishvarya Kavi

Most of the protesters at Columbus Circle, outside of Union Station, have moved back, but more than 100 remain and have begun chanting “Free Palestine” again.

Aishvarya Kavi

The Park police said they arrested two people at Columbus Circle, in front of Union Station.

Image

Credit…Eric Lee/The New York Times

Maya C. Miller

Some congressional staff aides walked out in protest ahead of Netanyahu’s speech.

Image

New York Police Department officers helped with security in the Capitol ahead of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s address to Congress on Wednesday.Credit…Kenny Holston/The New York Times

A group of congressional aides walked out of their Capitol offices in protest as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel prepared to address a joint meeting of Congress on Wednesday, joining thousands of protesters who gathered in the streets to denounce him and his conduct of the war against Hamas.

Roughly 50 House and Senate staff members, some concealing their identities behind sunglasses and black KN95 masks, carried blood-red carnations as they gathered in front of the U.S. Department of Labor building on Constitution Avenue.

In a statement, one organizer with the group, Congressional Staff for a Ceasefire Now, who identified himself only as Ishmael and a Palestinian American, listed its demands: “Stop funding this war against civilians. Send meals, not missiles. Secure the release of Israeli hostages and arbitrarily detained Palestinians. And use the leverage the American people have paid for to establish a lasting cease-fire that will bring an end to this brutal war.”

The staff members, wearing business suits and dresses, unfurled a banner with the phrase, “Staff say kick the war criminal out of our Capitol!”

The walkout was the latest in a series of high-profile yet fully anonymous actions that congressional aides have taken in recent months to publicly urge members of Congress — their own bosses — to call for a cease-fire in Gaza and halt shipments of U.S.-made weapons to Israel.

As part of a vigil last November, more than 100 staff members covered the Capitol steps with nearly 10,000 carnations to represent each life lost in the Israel-Hamas war up to that point. More than 38,000 people have been killed in Gaza during the Israeli military campaign, according to the Gazan Health Ministry.

Earlier this month, the Congressional Progressive Staff Association urged lawmakers to protest or boycott Mr. Netanyahu’s speech. They circulated a letter supported by 230 House and Senate aides, who declined to give their names, from across 122 Democratic and Republican congressional offices.

Congressional aides who have broken with their bosses on the situation in Gaza have almost all done so anonymously, fearful of losing their jobs or being penalized for publicly taking a stance at odds with the member of Congress they serve — an action considered egregious on Capitol Hill.

Also on Wednesday, a group of nearly 100 House and Senate interns called in sick to protest Mr. Netanyahu’s speech. In a statement, the interns called on their bosses to boycott the address.

“We urge our representatives to respond to the collective will of the American people and reject any semblance of endorsement for Netanyahu’s actions.”

Annie Karni

In a post online, Senator Chris Murphy, Democrat of Connecticut, who in the past has signaled he is open to placing conditions on aid to Israel, criticized the Netanyahu speech. “I’ve spent my career fighting for a strong U.S.-Israel relationship. I want Hamas defeated,” he wrote. “That speech was, as I expected, a setback for both the U.S.-Israel relationship and the fight against Hamas.”

Farnaz Fassihi

Mercy Corps, an international aid agency operating in Gaza, said that while Netanyahu was speaking in Congress, the humanitarian situation in Gaza was “in a nosedive.” Kate Phillips-Barrasso, the agency’s vice president of global policy, said in a statement: “No humanitarian goods are crossing into Gaza via Kerem Shalom because the unloading zone has been full for weeks. High insecurity, lawlessness, and bombardments in areas under Israeli military operation make collection and distribution impossible.”

Aishvarya Kavi

Protesters are leaving Union Station and the crowds are thinning out. There are still more than a hundred spread out but demonstrations and chants have mostly stopped.

Adam Goldman

The bell outside Union Station bears graffiti protesting the war, and demonstrators raised the Palestinian flag atop a flagpole outside the station.

Aishvarya Kavi

Protesters have set an effigy of Netanyahu on fire outside the station. There is black smoke rising and filling the area.

Image

Credit…Eric Lee/The New York Times

Video

CreditCredit…Aishvarya Kavi/The New York Times

Aishvarya Kavi

There is a huge contingent of police on the ground today. I’ve seen personnel and vehicles from the U.S. Capitol police, Park police, D.C.’s Metropolitan Police Department, the F.B.I., the New York Police Department and two different Maryland jurisdictions.

Image

Credit…Eric Lee/The New York Times

Euan Ward

Netanyahu’s speech touched only sporadically on the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah, though the risk of all-out war between the two sides is now higher than ever. The Biden administration has scrambled to contain the fighting in recent months, fearing a wider regional conflagration that could draw in the United States and Iran.

Erica L. Green

In his address, Netanyahu did not mention a cease-fire by name, or discuss the status of the deal that Israel and Hamas have been negotiating for weeks and that the Biden administration desperately wants to get done. He did say that the war could end if Hamas surrenders, disarms and returned hostages.

Robert Jimison

The address displayed a deep understanding of communication in American politics. Netanyahu was able to simultaneously strike defiant tones to deliver a number thinly veiled rebukes at President Biden and his administration while also finding space in his remarks to praise him and laud the ironclad relationship between the United States and Israel.

Patrick Kingsley

Netanyahu stuck to familiar talking points — on the war, on his plans for postwar Gaza, on Iran, and on the U.S.-Israel alliance. Here in Israel, we’ll be watching to see whether it helps him in the polls, or whether it simply galvanizes his base. Netanyahu’s poll ratings have ebbed since the war began. His speech to Congress was in part an attempt to remind Israelis of his experience on the world stage, at a time of national peril. Will it be enough?

Farnaz Fassihi

Netanyahu called for a regional alliance against Iran based on the Abraham Accords, but in recent years Iran has strengthened ties with Arab neighbors who have also signaled they have no intention to fight Iran. Iran has been normalizing relations with Saudi Arabia, improved ties with the United Arab Emirates and is in diplomatic talks with Egypt and Bahrain to restore ties.

David E. Sanger

Netanyahu gave a powerful speech. He stayed at 30,000 feet, praising the Israeli-American alliance, avoiding the sharp differences between himself and Biden, and not even mentioning Kamala Harris, whom he will meet on Thursday. He sounded more like an American president giving a State of the Union address, but his goal was to repair the breach.

Ephrat Livni

Netanyahu says that he came to Congress to thank the United States on behalf of the people of Israel. But many Israelis say that Netanyahu should not have accepted the invitation to address Congress at a time of so much trouble at home.

Image

Credit…Kenny Holston/The New York Times

Patrick Kingsley

Netanyahu extols Israel’s democracy. His opponents in Israel say he has endangered that democracy by trying to change its judicial system. Palestinians say there is no democracy without equal rights in the West Bank and Gaza.